This is a tremendously good, nuanced treatment of this issue. Thank you Natalie, you are a national treasure.
I think of direct instruction in reading lessons like this: the goal is for kids to deeply understand and anlayze THIS rich text. What are the barriers? What are the words that they might not know that will prevent them from understanding that Brutus is comparing Caesar to a serpent's egg because, while he is not dangerous now, he will be when he becomes king. Go after those words, while still always keeping the deep analytical level as the ultimate goal- kids need to explain the deeper meaning of that metaphor in Act 2, Scene 1 (or whatever it is you are teaching). And, I think the insight of the direct instruction stuff is just this: when kids don't "get it," it's not because of some deficiency with their abstract critical thinking skills that prevents them from understanding Shakespeare's metaphors. It's that they might not know a serpent is a snake. Teach them that, in the moment that the misunderstanding appears, and then ask them again: So, why is Brutus comparing Caesar to a serpent's egg?
Yes! Teaching well often includes a variety of instructional approaches that fit the purpose for learning. Instruction for deep understanding will look different than instruction to teach a specific fact.
Lots of scattered thoughts follow, but I really appreciated this piece.
First, I think there's a lot we can learn from DI and Engelmann...but like you, I have so many questions about how DI works/is effective beyond developing foundational math, reading, and language skills.
Second, I'm not sure if you'd read this recent study from Jake Downs and Freddy Hiebert, but it basically compares Corrective Reading (DI program) to Read Like Us protocol (scaffolded and structured fluency routine with above grade-level text) and finds that struggling 3rd graders grew more when they worked with more challenging texts (https://ila.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1002/rrq.70117). I hope Hanford takes the time to dive into this kind of nuance...
Third, I recently got into a baffling exchange on Twitter/X with a DI advocate about read-alouds with embedded questions. I walked away wondering if he believed that students should be allowed to analyze, interpret, and develop their own ideas at all.
Linda obviously knows a lot more about DI than I do, so I'll defer to her on that. But it's not what DI has become known for -- and more importantly, it's almost certainly not the view of DI that listeners to Sold a Story will come away with.
I read this piece, and while I'll defer to Linda's expertise too, it doesn't really clarify what knowledge-building looks like in Reading Mastery Signature Edition. I continue to be curious about opportunities for students to elaborate on, analyze, and make meaning of what they're reading.
You can also see sample lessons on this page. I haven't reviewed all of them, but the excerpts I did look at are fairly skills-forward, as is the scope and sequence. Hope to spend more time with them later...
The real question here is why are you mischaracterizing DI? Why write about it? Why not do more research before you make a comment? There is more wrong with some of the details of what you have written here. You should seriously redact this.
As I tried to make clear in my post, I am writing about DI as it is being portrayed via Sold a Story, which is the only source of information most listeners will probably have about DI.
No, you are misrepresenintg DI. A line like " many middle-class and affluent parents areunlikely to enroll their students in a school that limits early language instruction to words like button and collar." shows you have no idea how these programs are constructed, how they work, and how they are meant to be implemented. You are using Hanford's quality reporting to spread your pet projects and ideas. That is what you are doing.
Natalie, I think you have identified (in this and previous posts) the next challenge for Australia. Our education policy makers have grasped the benefits of direct instruction (which we call explicit instruction) but for optimal learning, explicit instruction is necessary but insufficient. Teacher training in Australia needs further work, correcting the idea 'explicit instruction is BEST' to 'explicit instruction is ONE critical part of effective teaching'. You say it so well 👏👏👏:
"The principles of direct instruction have caught on more in some other countries... When I visited some Australian schools serving kids who struggle academically, I saw a lot of the questioning and repetition that is associated with DI and very little else. Some educators there seem to have gotten the idea that analytical discussion and writing must wait until some undefined point in the future when their students will have acquired lots of information about the world. But that kind of discussion and writing is actually part of learning. Students need a certain amount of information to begin to engage in those activities profitably, but they don’t need to have become experts. And by reflecting on and analyzing what they’ve learned, they can deepen their understanding"
Know your students, "with Engelmann focusing on how to teach and Hirsch on what to teach. Neither model is complete, but if applied judiciously in tandem, the two approaches could be hugely powerful." As a ELD and Reading Intervention teacher of a K-5 Title 1 school that uses CKLA-skills and knowledge K-2 and knowledge 3-5, I know when to use both DI and when to dive deeper into knowledge to support extended writing and speaking. It seems we often don't give teachers credit for their capacity to integrate and personalize instruction for the population that they teach.
It's striking how much additional background information adds to comprehension. When I was a teenager, I read all of James Clavell's books. I enjoyed them; I followed the story fine, etc.
Recently, hearing Shogun was made into a TV show prompted me to pick them up again and re-read. In the 20 years that has elapsed, I've gained a lot more knowledge. In particular, within the past few years, I listened to Dan Carlin's 20+ hour series "Supernova in the East" that begins with Commodore Perry and goes up to WW2, as well as Tom Holland's "Dominion" that details the spread of Christianity.
Now, re-reading Clavell's novels, there's whole subplots that went right by me the first time, because I didn't have all this additional knowledge to place it in context 20 years ago. Even to read literature, there's a lot of background knowledge you need to have in place to understand fully... even an expression like "sour grapes" or "flying too close to the sun."
The idea of memorizing the basics of canonical stories like mythology, proverbs, fables, etc seems wrong to many people. I can't speak to a classroom curriculum, because we're just homeschool parents, but we have incorporated this with our daughter. Far from making reading a chore, it seems to fuel a love of reading, because it's more fun to understand the things you read and less fun to not understand them. Even a "kid's" movie like Shrek is way more fun to watch if you understand what it is parodying.
I appreciate your discussing what we education activists have known and fought about for decades, but there is nothing new here. The public schools have been a disaster for generations. Their administrators have no regard whatsoever for facts, research, working curriculum, or parents; public school administrations are completely controlled by other interests whose purposes are in total conflict with ours. It gets tiresome after awhile listening to right-minded academics discussing the obvious as if discussing it again were going to change anything. At some point we must also acknowledge the political realities and understand that there is no saving this thing, and that our only course forward is to completely abandon our gargantuan disaster and build something completely new from scratch. "No, we are not going to fix the public schools": https://daveziffer.substack.com/p/no-we-are-not-going-to-fix-the-public
And this is exactly why parents (me included) are taking their children out of "good" public school systems and putting them into private schools. I simply gave up trying and having to fill in the huge gaps at home (it made me the bad guy in my own home).
Wow does that ring a bell. When my wife finally convinced me to check out how utterly clueless our daughter was upon entering fourth grade, we discussed the possibility of giving her supplemental instruction at home. But then we realized that we were rationalizing: why should we have her largely waste seven hours per day and then relinquish her free time? That's when we started home schooling.
You already have the option to personally, individually, and legally abandon the schools; all you need do is reorganize your priorities, pull your kids out, and educate them yourself or in a private school. It's not even that hard; millions of us have already done it. Conversely, in my decades of education activism I've never seen anyone succeed at your proposal. When you can provide a practical, legal demonstration of your much grander plan, I will be most interested in seeing it.
I did that for seven years before giving up, realizing that I might as well be swimming against a tidal wave. You might want to read my article before going that route. But nonetheless, good luck.
Natalie, thank you for this. Your point that the parts need to be looked at closely, not just adopted wholesale, is exactly where my mind went too.
I agree that explicit instruction has been undervalued. But I keep thinking about the cold calling they talked in Episode 1. In my work as a literacy consultant, I hear from many teachers who are concerned about anxiety interfering with learning, and the research backs them up. Eysenck and colleagues’ attentional control theory describes how worry competes for the same cognitive resources needed for the task. Ashcraft and Kirk found math anxiety reduces working memory during problem solving, and Sian Beilock’s work shows how pressure leads students to “choke.”
I also see this up close as a parent. My daughter is brilliant, and she has ADHD and anxiety. I get the details of how anxiety interferes with her ability to focus in school. There are lots of ways to include her in a lesson, but if you tell her she could be called on publicly at any time, that is all she will focus on.
I know cold calling helps many students, and DI’s corrections are designed to end in success. But DI can’t be reduced to “just do it, it’s in the script.” If we embrace the research on explicit instruction while ignoring the research on anxiety and working memory, we’re cherry-picking research. Season 1 rightly took parents of children with dyslexia seriously. I hope Season 2 and or conversations about direct instruction gives the same weight to the teachers and parents raising this concern (This is just one of many concerns).
As I've argued elsewhere, I believe explicit writing instruction embedded in the content of the curriculum can accomplish many of the things that DI aims for -- like retrieval practice -- along with providing opportunities for analysis and elaboration that reach every student in a classroom (plus familiarizing kids with complex syntax). And perhaps an added benefit is that it may be easier for students to respond in writing if cold calling makes them anxious.
With DI proper, if a student is placed appropriately, which is how the entire system is designed, then they will know about 90% of material and it is scaffolded. Anxiety is not a major concern and the repsonses are largely in unison or for conirmation and firming up students with support. Both this article and your comments only show a misunderstanding of how these programs are constructed, how they work, and what they can do.
Check out the video on Sold A Story. I’m unable to post it here. It’s the only video posted so far as an example of direct instruction That is why I brought up cold calling. Contrary to what you said, I fully understand that direct instruction can be different but I hope this example doesn’t end up being the only example. My concern is not about direct instruction. My worry is about too simple a version of direct instruction being understood by people watching and decisions they will make after watching it. I’m telling you firsthand as a parent, not as educator that anxiety about cold calling has been a major concern for my daughter and her story and others like her in the school system should be listened to. Thankfully most teachers across her schooling have listened and given her other ways to show what knows. I want this to work for all students which is why I am bringing up the nuances, not because I have ‘misunderstood’ I wish people would take the time to understand rather than quickly dismiss. Writing is something I often talk about in my literacy work as a way to show understanding rather than cold calling if the situation or the student warrants it.
Yeah, I really wish people writing things like this actually understood or have implemented various DI sequences for some time before confusing people, like Natalie is doing here in full force. While there is some encouragement to check students understanding who do not answer properly in unison as a diagnostic point, the core of DI is unison responding. If a student is properly placed they will not need much cold calling and if they do they are well within the frame of understanding where it will be useful and relevant to give them understanding and further confidence to move forward. More importantly, and to speak to your main point, an intelligent instructor will clearly adjust and not do that for a student like yours.
As for teachers "going off script" it is absolutely insane how many teachers think they "know better" than a solid instructional designer. They are two completley different jobs. I've never met a teacher, self included ( working at a doctoral level of understanding), be able to make curriculum well on top of teaching a the same time. While there are sure times and ways this might happen, it is a double edged sword, and the hubris in this field is off the charts with what teachers think they know about their students or how to help them.
All of this is particularly true when compared to someone like Zig and his crew. These peple literally figured out how to teach in ways that parallel our best educational science decades before it was confirmed. They figured out ways to scale it into entire systems through these scripts. This is a MASSIVE feat. This man was literally a genius. People who don't get this know little about education or DI or both.
While DI does not answer everything in our systems and tweaks can be made here and there, if it was ever disemmenated at the levels that Project Follow Through or Stockard's recent 50 YEAR META warranted, we would be living in a completely different world considering the influence our country has on the rest of the world. I wish people would wake up already. Actually look at the science and research on this approach, its irrefutable. For those who have never implemented it properly, it's just the same story again.
"But it’s not clear from the podcast how they progressed from learning words like button to reading Macbeth, nor is it clear how much of the school’s curriculum was grounded in DI as opposed to the ideas of its dynamic principal."
Thank you for asking all the right questions. I hope you'll keep asking them.
After teaching kindergarten for 29 years, I retired early, and not because of the kids. The powers that be were switching up our reading instruction (and other subjects) with every swearing in of a new governor. Nothing is in the best interest of the students or teachers. It's all political. For years, I've said I was going to write a book exposing everything I've learned. There's so much, I don't know where to start. Can anyone point me in the right direction?
Replacing Hirsch’s offensive word CULTURAL with the word academic does not change the idea that there is some set of knowledge that kids growing up in privileged environments naturally know and kids from less privileged communities must learn in order to keep up (or assimilate.) This frame assumes that one set of knowledge is more valuable than another. It is essential to working with children to understand the funds of knowledge that they bring to the table and to build on and honor that knowledge.
The world needs people who know how to learn, how to investigate, how to problem solve. Kids need experiences asking questions, finding answers, and designing solutions. A child who can tell you about the history and ecology of the Bronx River, the activism that has led to its revival, and the environmental impact of different interventions is just as ready to run the world (maybe more so) than the child who can tell you about the details of the civil war.
When you carry a world of knowledge on a small piece of glass in your pocket, what matters is whether you know how to use it.
Hirsch wasn't arguing for familiarizing kids with Western culture (or whatever you want to call it) because he felt it was "more valuable" than other kinds of cultural knowledge. He was arguing for it because he felt poor kids would be at a disadvantage in life if they didn't know it. And I agree with him.
But the key thing is to build a critical mass of general knowledge and vocabulary that will enable students to understand the kinds of texts and information they'll encounter throughout their lives. Maybe learning about the Bronx River will accomplish that -- I don't know. It would depend at least partly on what vocabulary kids are acquiring as a result.
At the same time, I do think that anyone graduating from high school should know something about the Civil War. The community college students Hirsch was testing apparently didn't know who Ulysses S. Grant and Robert E. Lee were. I don't call that a "detail." And even college students can't always identify who WON the Civil War (see https://www.npr.org/sections/theprotojournalist/2014/11/18/364675234/who-won-the-civil-war-tough-question). Again, not a detail.
Knowing "how to learn", "investigate" and "problem solve" are skils that are domain specific and fundamentally built on knowledge in your brain. You might know how to investigate the ecology of the Bronx river while being hopeless at investigating a plumbing leak in your house. This is not to say that either is more important than the other, but that knowledge is it's foundation and you can't teach skills in lieu of knowledge. This rhetoric is part of how we ended up here in the first place.
Having knowledge on your smartphone is also very different to having it in your head. Having knowledge readily accessible from long term memory is what allows the higher order thinking to happen. Otherwise, you either offload the thinking entirely (hand it to AI) or you are overloaded with the lower level knowledge (filling up your working memory).
It's also impossible to know what questions to ask when you have no foundational knowledge to ground it. I'd bet the kids who "know how to use knowledge" are also the kids who have the knowledge in the first place.
Hearing the word "cultural" as _offensive_ is ridiculous.
Hirsch was exploring what knowledge readers needed to understand mainstream articles in the New York Times and Time magazine and so forth--hardly "academic," but more like _basic level of competence_ . There's no good reason to exclude children from participating in the general discussion (talk / writing in the media, schools, universities, daily life, etc.) by refusing to teach them the topics that the larger culture takes for granted.
I fear this cataloguing of skills like “learning,” “problem solving,” “investigation” is exactly the teaching philosophy that has failed so many children. In my son’s 5th he class (Northern CA public school) on posters around the classroom were are all these hints on how to analyze fiction that seems to belong in a freshman comp lit course.
Name the main idea. Name how a character changed their mind. What is presented as facts. As opinions?
The teacher had a creative book report series that parents were invited to attend and it was clear only 30% of the class actually understood and internalized the short novels they each read.
That’s not to say these skills are not important. Any democracy absolutely needs these. But they don’t exist without the substrate of a deep knowledge base. It can be Western Civilization. It can be Chinese history, literature and philosophy. Or Indian. It can be Sumerian culture and mathematics for all I care. It can be the rich culture of Eastern Woodland aboriginal Americans. But you need to have learned a knowledge base so that you later reflect on the skills you used and honed. It reminds me of Hegel quote (which I paraphrase): the Minerva of philosophy flies at dusk.
Wait for the knowledge to be there- then we talk about the techniques that built it and builds on it.
I lack a full understanding of the American context, but I’m not sure I fully understand some of the concerns expressed regarding Season 2’s potential to acerbate inequality. I doubt Ms. Hanford believes different socio-economic classes should be given different curriculums and pedagogy…
I completely agree, though, with your general point that there is clearly a profound insight in Hirsch and the CK movement that DI misses. But generally, the two ideas are much more complementary than competitive.
Direct Instruction’s approach to math teaching, especially in the early years, is simply brilliant. But I think most of us can agree that the Direct Instruction methods of “atomizing” instruction don’t really lend themselves to illuminating grand historical narratives, for example.
I think, though, that even if just from a pedagogical perspective, some of the DI methods for corralling and maintaining student attention and engagement can make a huge difference when applied to the instruction of knowledge rich curriculums.
For example, a ton of the Language Arts lessons in the fabulous Core Knowledge Curriculum could be enhanced with a simple integration of some DI group reading and choral response techniques.
I'm interested in Episode 3 now ... I've only heard episode 1.
I agree there's a grey area for direct instruction and it think the social constructs of ones world and experiences do help bridge the gaps of comprehension capabilities, however nuanced they may be, and incredibly difficult to artificially create.
Thank you for sharing your perspective. I think we must maintain a clear distinction between constructivist inquiry and true direct instruction. Workshop models like Lucy Calkins’ rely on discovery-based learning for writing and comprehension, assuming children will naturally deduce spelling, syntax, and text analysis through open-ended engagement. However, asking students to "discover" literacy mechanics overloads working memory. Literacy is fundamentally an encoding and decoding process that requires explicit scaffolding rather than unguided inquiry, and constructivist frameworks should not be conflated with structured teaching.
Furthermore, framing strategy instruction as a mere artifact of balanced literacy minimizes decades of empirical work by pioneers like Jeanne Chall, Jan Hasbrouck, Sharon Vaughn, and Alice Ansara. Their research demonstrates that explicit instruction in active comprehension tools—such as text structure, self-monitoring, and vocabulary processing—is essential for enabling students, particularly struggling readers, to access and synthesize complex texts. Comprehension is the ultimate end-goal skill, but accessing it requires tactical, evidence-based instruction alongside domain-knowledge building.
Finally, when addressing writing, J. Richard Gentry’s developmental framework remains a critical missing link in the current reform debate. Gentry proved that explicit spelling and transcription instruction directly drive orthographic mapping, freeing up the cognitive architecture required for higher-order composition and comprehension. Leaving children stranded in unguided, constructivist "invented spelling" directly impairs their fluency and writing development. To truly fix classroom instruction, we must recognize that comprehension and written expression are complex outcomes built through explicit, systematic instruction in language mechanics, spelling, and content. I say this as an adult who was never properly identified as dyslexic in school, but I benefitted from direct instruction from my teachers. I always scored high on comprehension because later on in the "no child left behind" era they explicitly taught how to understand comprehension questions on a CRCT test format. This applied to accelerated reading tests as well. So in a world where most kids aren't assessed comprehension through an oral exam or a book report, but usually through an online multiple choice format. I think we need to include the direct instruction of test taking skills as well.
The distinction you draw — Engelmann on how to teach, Hirsch on what to teach — is the point I will take away.
In our work with older pupils, the same tension appears in reverse: they can discuss a text fluently, until a missing piece of knowledge shows the discussion was resting on very little.
Analysis cannot wait until knowledge is complete, as you say — but it cannot float without it either.
Although there are portions of this article that I do find interesting and relevant to my work in the classroom, articles like this and the discussion that often follows emphasizes the great divide between “the experts” and those of us who do the actual work with children.
As I read about direct instruction, it is not theory to me. It is the wiggly bodies of 5 year olds trying their best to listen but wishing they were anywhere but here. Yes, I understand and agree that in order to learn something new there is an element of direct instruction that has to happen. But the developmental needs of students needs to be taken into account and articles like this and the re-emphasis on direct instruction does damage to real kids. Many will misinterpret these theories and take it as an easy pass to again go back to being the sage on the stage who requires little bodies to stay still and compliant while they drone on endlessly. It truly doesn’t matter what is being taught at that point.
I wonder how many of these experts have taught kindergarten, first grade, fifth grade? For more than 5 years? These are real children that we are talking about with real needs and curiosities and we as teachers are endlessly dynamic in order to best meet those needs. We don’t need experts oversimplifying our daily challenges.
As someone who has observed and delivered a lot of dynamic instruction in my over two decade career, the instructional examples in this video make me cringe. You may notice that in every case they are learning very simple discrete skills like times tables or reading at the word level.
This is a very specific technique that should be used for a very specific set of objectives. This show and its proponents have over generalized this strategy. This is just one of MANY effective instructional strategies that we as teachers have to choose from.
If you watch the videos of kids learning (See this 5 minute one https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gDUMHdqcve4) you can see real children who look to me like they are having fun and learning. I don't see a teacher droning on and on.
This is a tremendously good, nuanced treatment of this issue. Thank you Natalie, you are a national treasure.
I think of direct instruction in reading lessons like this: the goal is for kids to deeply understand and anlayze THIS rich text. What are the barriers? What are the words that they might not know that will prevent them from understanding that Brutus is comparing Caesar to a serpent's egg because, while he is not dangerous now, he will be when he becomes king. Go after those words, while still always keeping the deep analytical level as the ultimate goal- kids need to explain the deeper meaning of that metaphor in Act 2, Scene 1 (or whatever it is you are teaching). And, I think the insight of the direct instruction stuff is just this: when kids don't "get it," it's not because of some deficiency with their abstract critical thinking skills that prevents them from understanding Shakespeare's metaphors. It's that they might not know a serpent is a snake. Teach them that, in the moment that the misunderstanding appears, and then ask them again: So, why is Brutus comparing Caesar to a serpent's egg?
Yes! Teaching well often includes a variety of instructional approaches that fit the purpose for learning. Instruction for deep understanding will look different than instruction to teach a specific fact.
Lots of scattered thoughts follow, but I really appreciated this piece.
First, I think there's a lot we can learn from DI and Engelmann...but like you, I have so many questions about how DI works/is effective beyond developing foundational math, reading, and language skills.
Second, I'm not sure if you'd read this recent study from Jake Downs and Freddy Hiebert, but it basically compares Corrective Reading (DI program) to Read Like Us protocol (scaffolded and structured fluency routine with above grade-level text) and finds that struggling 3rd graders grew more when they worked with more challenging texts (https://ila.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1002/rrq.70117). I hope Hanford takes the time to dive into this kind of nuance...
Third, I recently got into a baffling exchange on Twitter/X with a DI advocate about read-alouds with embedded questions. I walked away wondering if he believed that students should be allowed to analyze, interpret, and develop their own ideas at all.
I did just come across this post by Linda Diamond arguing that DI actually does build knowledge:
https://substack.com/home/post/p-220567609
Linda obviously knows a lot more about DI than I do, so I'll defer to her on that. But it's not what DI has become known for -- and more importantly, it's almost certainly not the view of DI that listeners to Sold a Story will come away with.
I read this piece, and while I'll defer to Linda's expertise too, it doesn't really clarify what knowledge-building looks like in Reading Mastery Signature Edition. I continue to be curious about opportunities for students to elaborate on, analyze, and make meaning of what they're reading.
I did find the scope and sequence for Reading Mastery Signature Edition on the McGraw Hill website. The program appears to separate "reading" and "language arts." https://www.mheducation.com/prek-12/program/reading-mastery-signature-edition/MKTSP-UQM08M02.html?srsltid=AU7gw4UCQ8j_LX5xOrGFn-Lx4hqS43bNewaD8oMHfmcAHsOXBH00UJqm#resources
You can also see sample lessons on this page. I haven't reviewed all of them, but the excerpts I did look at are fairly skills-forward, as is the scope and sequence. Hope to spend more time with them later...
"I continue to be curious about opportunities for students to elaborate on, analyze, and make meaning of what they're reading."
I had exactly the same impressions you did about skills-forward lessons.
The real question here is why are you mischaracterizing DI? Why write about it? Why not do more research before you make a comment? There is more wrong with some of the details of what you have written here. You should seriously redact this.
As I tried to make clear in my post, I am writing about DI as it is being portrayed via Sold a Story, which is the only source of information most listeners will probably have about DI.
No, you are misrepresenintg DI. A line like " many middle-class and affluent parents areunlikely to enroll their students in a school that limits early language instruction to words like button and collar." shows you have no idea how these programs are constructed, how they work, and how they are meant to be implemented. You are using Hanford's quality reporting to spread your pet projects and ideas. That is what you are doing.
Natalie, I think you have identified (in this and previous posts) the next challenge for Australia. Our education policy makers have grasped the benefits of direct instruction (which we call explicit instruction) but for optimal learning, explicit instruction is necessary but insufficient. Teacher training in Australia needs further work, correcting the idea 'explicit instruction is BEST' to 'explicit instruction is ONE critical part of effective teaching'. You say it so well 👏👏👏:
"The principles of direct instruction have caught on more in some other countries... When I visited some Australian schools serving kids who struggle academically, I saw a lot of the questioning and repetition that is associated with DI and very little else. Some educators there seem to have gotten the idea that analytical discussion and writing must wait until some undefined point in the future when their students will have acquired lots of information about the world. But that kind of discussion and writing is actually part of learning. Students need a certain amount of information to begin to engage in those activities profitably, but they don’t need to have become experts. And by reflecting on and analyzing what they’ve learned, they can deepen their understanding"
Know your students, "with Engelmann focusing on how to teach and Hirsch on what to teach. Neither model is complete, but if applied judiciously in tandem, the two approaches could be hugely powerful." As a ELD and Reading Intervention teacher of a K-5 Title 1 school that uses CKLA-skills and knowledge K-2 and knowledge 3-5, I know when to use both DI and when to dive deeper into knowledge to support extended writing and speaking. It seems we often don't give teachers credit for their capacity to integrate and personalize instruction for the population that they teach.
It's striking how much additional background information adds to comprehension. When I was a teenager, I read all of James Clavell's books. I enjoyed them; I followed the story fine, etc.
Recently, hearing Shogun was made into a TV show prompted me to pick them up again and re-read. In the 20 years that has elapsed, I've gained a lot more knowledge. In particular, within the past few years, I listened to Dan Carlin's 20+ hour series "Supernova in the East" that begins with Commodore Perry and goes up to WW2, as well as Tom Holland's "Dominion" that details the spread of Christianity.
Now, re-reading Clavell's novels, there's whole subplots that went right by me the first time, because I didn't have all this additional knowledge to place it in context 20 years ago. Even to read literature, there's a lot of background knowledge you need to have in place to understand fully... even an expression like "sour grapes" or "flying too close to the sun."
The idea of memorizing the basics of canonical stories like mythology, proverbs, fables, etc seems wrong to many people. I can't speak to a classroom curriculum, because we're just homeschool parents, but we have incorporated this with our daughter. Far from making reading a chore, it seems to fuel a love of reading, because it's more fun to understand the things you read and less fun to not understand them. Even a "kid's" movie like Shrek is way more fun to watch if you understand what it is parodying.
I appreciate your discussing what we education activists have known and fought about for decades, but there is nothing new here. The public schools have been a disaster for generations. Their administrators have no regard whatsoever for facts, research, working curriculum, or parents; public school administrations are completely controlled by other interests whose purposes are in total conflict with ours. It gets tiresome after awhile listening to right-minded academics discussing the obvious as if discussing it again were going to change anything. At some point we must also acknowledge the political realities and understand that there is no saving this thing, and that our only course forward is to completely abandon our gargantuan disaster and build something completely new from scratch. "No, we are not going to fix the public schools": https://daveziffer.substack.com/p/no-we-are-not-going-to-fix-the-public
And this is exactly why parents (me included) are taking their children out of "good" public school systems and putting them into private schools. I simply gave up trying and having to fill in the huge gaps at home (it made me the bad guy in my own home).
Wow does that ring a bell. When my wife finally convinced me to check out how utterly clueless our daughter was upon entering fourth grade, we discussed the possibility of giving her supplemental instruction at home. But then we realized that we were rationalizing: why should we have her largely waste seven hours per day and then relinquish her free time? That's when we started home schooling.
Horrendous take. Public schools need to be remade by force, not abandoned completely.
You already have the option to personally, individually, and legally abandon the schools; all you need do is reorganize your priorities, pull your kids out, and educate them yourself or in a private school. It's not even that hard; millions of us have already done it. Conversely, in my decades of education activism I've never seen anyone succeed at your proposal. When you can provide a practical, legal demonstration of your much grander plan, I will be most interested in seeing it.
I will not be doing any of that. I will be fighting for public schools to better serve their students.
I did that for seven years before giving up, realizing that I might as well be swimming against a tidal wave. You might want to read my article before going that route. But nonetheless, good luck.
Natalie, thank you for this. Your point that the parts need to be looked at closely, not just adopted wholesale, is exactly where my mind went too.
I agree that explicit instruction has been undervalued. But I keep thinking about the cold calling they talked in Episode 1. In my work as a literacy consultant, I hear from many teachers who are concerned about anxiety interfering with learning, and the research backs them up. Eysenck and colleagues’ attentional control theory describes how worry competes for the same cognitive resources needed for the task. Ashcraft and Kirk found math anxiety reduces working memory during problem solving, and Sian Beilock’s work shows how pressure leads students to “choke.”
I also see this up close as a parent. My daughter is brilliant, and she has ADHD and anxiety. I get the details of how anxiety interferes with her ability to focus in school. There are lots of ways to include her in a lesson, but if you tell her she could be called on publicly at any time, that is all she will focus on.
I know cold calling helps many students, and DI’s corrections are designed to end in success. But DI can’t be reduced to “just do it, it’s in the script.” If we embrace the research on explicit instruction while ignoring the research on anxiety and working memory, we’re cherry-picking research. Season 1 rightly took parents of children with dyslexia seriously. I hope Season 2 and or conversations about direct instruction gives the same weight to the teachers and parents raising this concern (This is just one of many concerns).
As I've argued elsewhere, I believe explicit writing instruction embedded in the content of the curriculum can accomplish many of the things that DI aims for -- like retrieval practice -- along with providing opportunities for analysis and elaboration that reach every student in a classroom (plus familiarizing kids with complex syntax). And perhaps an added benefit is that it may be easier for students to respond in writing if cold calling makes them anxious.
With DI proper, if a student is placed appropriately, which is how the entire system is designed, then they will know about 90% of material and it is scaffolded. Anxiety is not a major concern and the repsonses are largely in unison or for conirmation and firming up students with support. Both this article and your comments only show a misunderstanding of how these programs are constructed, how they work, and what they can do.
Check out the video on Sold A Story. I’m unable to post it here. It’s the only video posted so far as an example of direct instruction That is why I brought up cold calling. Contrary to what you said, I fully understand that direct instruction can be different but I hope this example doesn’t end up being the only example. My concern is not about direct instruction. My worry is about too simple a version of direct instruction being understood by people watching and decisions they will make after watching it. I’m telling you firsthand as a parent, not as educator that anxiety about cold calling has been a major concern for my daughter and her story and others like her in the school system should be listened to. Thankfully most teachers across her schooling have listened and given her other ways to show what knows. I want this to work for all students which is why I am bringing up the nuances, not because I have ‘misunderstood’ I wish people would take the time to understand rather than quickly dismiss. Writing is something I often talk about in my literacy work as a way to show understanding rather than cold calling if the situation or the student warrants it.
This interaction and Natalie's article inspired me to watch the episodes carefully and think a bit more about my reflections. https://leahmermelstein.substack.com/p/were-more-alike-than-the-podcast?r=4uwjft&utm_campaign=post-expanded-share&utm_medium=web
Yeah, I really wish people writing things like this actually understood or have implemented various DI sequences for some time before confusing people, like Natalie is doing here in full force. While there is some encouragement to check students understanding who do not answer properly in unison as a diagnostic point, the core of DI is unison responding. If a student is properly placed they will not need much cold calling and if they do they are well within the frame of understanding where it will be useful and relevant to give them understanding and further confidence to move forward. More importantly, and to speak to your main point, an intelligent instructor will clearly adjust and not do that for a student like yours.
As for teachers "going off script" it is absolutely insane how many teachers think they "know better" than a solid instructional designer. They are two completley different jobs. I've never met a teacher, self included ( working at a doctoral level of understanding), be able to make curriculum well on top of teaching a the same time. While there are sure times and ways this might happen, it is a double edged sword, and the hubris in this field is off the charts with what teachers think they know about their students or how to help them.
All of this is particularly true when compared to someone like Zig and his crew. These peple literally figured out how to teach in ways that parallel our best educational science decades before it was confirmed. They figured out ways to scale it into entire systems through these scripts. This is a MASSIVE feat. This man was literally a genius. People who don't get this know little about education or DI or both.
While DI does not answer everything in our systems and tweaks can be made here and there, if it was ever disemmenated at the levels that Project Follow Through or Stockard's recent 50 YEAR META warranted, we would be living in a completely different world considering the influence our country has on the rest of the world. I wish people would wake up already. Actually look at the science and research on this approach, its irrefutable. For those who have never implemented it properly, it's just the same story again.
"But it’s not clear from the podcast how they progressed from learning words like button to reading Macbeth, nor is it clear how much of the school’s curriculum was grounded in DI as opposed to the ideas of its dynamic principal."
Thank you for asking all the right questions. I hope you'll keep asking them.
After teaching kindergarten for 29 years, I retired early, and not because of the kids. The powers that be were switching up our reading instruction (and other subjects) with every swearing in of a new governor. Nothing is in the best interest of the students or teachers. It's all political. For years, I've said I was going to write a book exposing everything I've learned. There's so much, I don't know where to start. Can anyone point me in the right direction?
Replacing Hirsch’s offensive word CULTURAL with the word academic does not change the idea that there is some set of knowledge that kids growing up in privileged environments naturally know and kids from less privileged communities must learn in order to keep up (or assimilate.) This frame assumes that one set of knowledge is more valuable than another. It is essential to working with children to understand the funds of knowledge that they bring to the table and to build on and honor that knowledge.
The world needs people who know how to learn, how to investigate, how to problem solve. Kids need experiences asking questions, finding answers, and designing solutions. A child who can tell you about the history and ecology of the Bronx River, the activism that has led to its revival, and the environmental impact of different interventions is just as ready to run the world (maybe more so) than the child who can tell you about the details of the civil war.
When you carry a world of knowledge on a small piece of glass in your pocket, what matters is whether you know how to use it.
Hirsch wasn't arguing for familiarizing kids with Western culture (or whatever you want to call it) because he felt it was "more valuable" than other kinds of cultural knowledge. He was arguing for it because he felt poor kids would be at a disadvantage in life if they didn't know it. And I agree with him.
But the key thing is to build a critical mass of general knowledge and vocabulary that will enable students to understand the kinds of texts and information they'll encounter throughout their lives. Maybe learning about the Bronx River will accomplish that -- I don't know. It would depend at least partly on what vocabulary kids are acquiring as a result.
At the same time, I do think that anyone graduating from high school should know something about the Civil War. The community college students Hirsch was testing apparently didn't know who Ulysses S. Grant and Robert E. Lee were. I don't call that a "detail." And even college students can't always identify who WON the Civil War (see https://www.npr.org/sections/theprotojournalist/2014/11/18/364675234/who-won-the-civil-war-tough-question). Again, not a detail.
Hard disagree with 2nd and 3rd paragraph.
Knowing "how to learn", "investigate" and "problem solve" are skils that are domain specific and fundamentally built on knowledge in your brain. You might know how to investigate the ecology of the Bronx river while being hopeless at investigating a plumbing leak in your house. This is not to say that either is more important than the other, but that knowledge is it's foundation and you can't teach skills in lieu of knowledge. This rhetoric is part of how we ended up here in the first place.
Having knowledge on your smartphone is also very different to having it in your head. Having knowledge readily accessible from long term memory is what allows the higher order thinking to happen. Otherwise, you either offload the thinking entirely (hand it to AI) or you are overloaded with the lower level knowledge (filling up your working memory).
It's also impossible to know what questions to ask when you have no foundational knowledge to ground it. I'd bet the kids who "know how to use knowledge" are also the kids who have the knowledge in the first place.
Hearing the word "cultural" as _offensive_ is ridiculous.
Hirsch was exploring what knowledge readers needed to understand mainstream articles in the New York Times and Time magazine and so forth--hardly "academic," but more like _basic level of competence_ . There's no good reason to exclude children from participating in the general discussion (talk / writing in the media, schools, universities, daily life, etc.) by refusing to teach them the topics that the larger culture takes for granted.
I fear this cataloguing of skills like “learning,” “problem solving,” “investigation” is exactly the teaching philosophy that has failed so many children. In my son’s 5th he class (Northern CA public school) on posters around the classroom were are all these hints on how to analyze fiction that seems to belong in a freshman comp lit course.
Name the main idea. Name how a character changed their mind. What is presented as facts. As opinions?
The teacher had a creative book report series that parents were invited to attend and it was clear only 30% of the class actually understood and internalized the short novels they each read.
That’s not to say these skills are not important. Any democracy absolutely needs these. But they don’t exist without the substrate of a deep knowledge base. It can be Western Civilization. It can be Chinese history, literature and philosophy. Or Indian. It can be Sumerian culture and mathematics for all I care. It can be the rich culture of Eastern Woodland aboriginal Americans. But you need to have learned a knowledge base so that you later reflect on the skills you used and honed. It reminds me of Hegel quote (which I paraphrase): the Minerva of philosophy flies at dusk.
Wait for the knowledge to be there- then we talk about the techniques that built it and builds on it.
I lack a full understanding of the American context, but I’m not sure I fully understand some of the concerns expressed regarding Season 2’s potential to acerbate inequality. I doubt Ms. Hanford believes different socio-economic classes should be given different curriculums and pedagogy…
I completely agree, though, with your general point that there is clearly a profound insight in Hirsch and the CK movement that DI misses. But generally, the two ideas are much more complementary than competitive.
Direct Instruction’s approach to math teaching, especially in the early years, is simply brilliant. But I think most of us can agree that the Direct Instruction methods of “atomizing” instruction don’t really lend themselves to illuminating grand historical narratives, for example.
I think, though, that even if just from a pedagogical perspective, some of the DI methods for corralling and maintaining student attention and engagement can make a huge difference when applied to the instruction of knowledge rich curriculums.
For example, a ton of the Language Arts lessons in the fabulous Core Knowledge Curriculum could be enhanced with a simple integration of some DI group reading and choral response techniques.
So I think two really can work together…
I'm interested in Episode 3 now ... I've only heard episode 1.
I agree there's a grey area for direct instruction and it think the social constructs of ones world and experiences do help bridge the gaps of comprehension capabilities, however nuanced they may be, and incredibly difficult to artificially create.
Here's my tale on Sold a Story and my questions: https://jodieadamantine.substack.com/p/we-had-the-evidence-what-we-did-with?utm_source=share&utm_medium=android&r=91hndu
The Simple View of Reading
Thank you for sharing your perspective. I think we must maintain a clear distinction between constructivist inquiry and true direct instruction. Workshop models like Lucy Calkins’ rely on discovery-based learning for writing and comprehension, assuming children will naturally deduce spelling, syntax, and text analysis through open-ended engagement. However, asking students to "discover" literacy mechanics overloads working memory. Literacy is fundamentally an encoding and decoding process that requires explicit scaffolding rather than unguided inquiry, and constructivist frameworks should not be conflated with structured teaching.
Furthermore, framing strategy instruction as a mere artifact of balanced literacy minimizes decades of empirical work by pioneers like Jeanne Chall, Jan Hasbrouck, Sharon Vaughn, and Alice Ansara. Their research demonstrates that explicit instruction in active comprehension tools—such as text structure, self-monitoring, and vocabulary processing—is essential for enabling students, particularly struggling readers, to access and synthesize complex texts. Comprehension is the ultimate end-goal skill, but accessing it requires tactical, evidence-based instruction alongside domain-knowledge building.
Finally, when addressing writing, J. Richard Gentry’s developmental framework remains a critical missing link in the current reform debate. Gentry proved that explicit spelling and transcription instruction directly drive orthographic mapping, freeing up the cognitive architecture required for higher-order composition and comprehension. Leaving children stranded in unguided, constructivist "invented spelling" directly impairs their fluency and writing development. To truly fix classroom instruction, we must recognize that comprehension and written expression are complex outcomes built through explicit, systematic instruction in language mechanics, spelling, and content. I say this as an adult who was never properly identified as dyslexic in school, but I benefitted from direct instruction from my teachers. I always scored high on comprehension because later on in the "no child left behind" era they explicitly taught how to understand comprehension questions on a CRCT test format. This applied to accelerated reading tests as well. So in a world where most kids aren't assessed comprehension through an oral exam or a book report, but usually through an online multiple choice format. I think we need to include the direct instruction of test taking skills as well.
The distinction you draw — Engelmann on how to teach, Hirsch on what to teach — is the point I will take away.
In our work with older pupils, the same tension appears in reverse: they can discuss a text fluently, until a missing piece of knowledge shows the discussion was resting on very little.
Analysis cannot wait until knowledge is complete, as you say — but it cannot float without it either.
Although there are portions of this article that I do find interesting and relevant to my work in the classroom, articles like this and the discussion that often follows emphasizes the great divide between “the experts” and those of us who do the actual work with children.
As I read about direct instruction, it is not theory to me. It is the wiggly bodies of 5 year olds trying their best to listen but wishing they were anywhere but here. Yes, I understand and agree that in order to learn something new there is an element of direct instruction that has to happen. But the developmental needs of students needs to be taken into account and articles like this and the re-emphasis on direct instruction does damage to real kids. Many will misinterpret these theories and take it as an easy pass to again go back to being the sage on the stage who requires little bodies to stay still and compliant while they drone on endlessly. It truly doesn’t matter what is being taught at that point.
I wonder how many of these experts have taught kindergarten, first grade, fifth grade? For more than 5 years? These are real children that we are talking about with real needs and curiosities and we as teachers are endlessly dynamic in order to best meet those needs. We don’t need experts oversimplifying our daily challenges.
As someone who has observed and delivered a lot of dynamic instruction in my over two decade career, the instructional examples in this video make me cringe. You may notice that in every case they are learning very simple discrete skills like times tables or reading at the word level.
This is a very specific technique that should be used for a very specific set of objectives. This show and its proponents have over generalized this strategy. This is just one of MANY effective instructional strategies that we as teachers have to choose from.
If you watch the videos of kids learning (See this 5 minute one https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gDUMHdqcve4) you can see real children who look to me like they are having fun and learning. I don't see a teacher droning on and on.